Understanding the Fascinating Appeal of Pain in Masochism
Written on
Chapter 1: The Paradox of Masochism
The concept of masochism is intriguing yet perplexing. Pain, a sensation evolved to protect us from harm, is typically something we strive to avoid. So, what compels masochists to seek out and even relish pain?
According to the International Association for the Study of Pain, pain is characterized as “an unpleasant sensory and emotional experience connected to actual or potential tissue damage.” However, if masochists derive pleasure from pain, can it still be classified as pain?
Wrong Interpretations of Masochistic Pain
This conundrum has long confounded psychologists, who have historically approached it with stigmatizing interpretations. Masochism was once categorized as a mental disorder that drives individuals to inflict harm upon themselves, but this notion has been debunked. It has been removed from the DSM-5, the American Psychiatric Association's authoritative guide to mental disorders. Furthermore, psychometric evaluations conducted on a group of BDSM practitioners revealed that they are psychologically akin to the general populace. Simply put, masochists are not mentally unstable.
Another misconception is that masochism is an exclusive practice engaged in by a small demographic. In reality, a comprehensive survey indicated that 66% of women and nearly 45% of men have experienced pleasurable spanking, while 20% of individuals of any gender have engaged in BDSM activities.
Interestingly, the enjoyment of pain extends beyond sexual contexts. For example, many cultures—such as those in India, Thailand, and Mexico—regularly consume spicy foods, which activates TRPV1, a protein that alerts the brain to painful heat. The researchers behind the discovery of TRPV1 were awarded the Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine in 2021.
Thus, the inclination to enjoy pain may be a fundamental aspect of human nature rather than solely sexual.
Possible Reasons Behind Masochism
Masochists might enjoy pain for its own sake, or they may use it as a means to achieve other ends, such as fulfilling a dominant partner's desires or attaining a trance-like state. This can be likened to the experience of athletes who endure physical discomfort to reach their goals. This concept is explored in the book It Hurts So Good, authored by a masochist sharing her insights.
To delve deeper into this topic, I conducted an informal survey on Fetlife.com, a social platform for individuals with alternative sexual preferences, boasting 10 million members globally. The survey posed the question: Why do you derive pleasure from pain?
- Enjoyment of pain itself
- Pain as a form of degradation and humility
- Pain as a sign of submission to a dominant partner
- Pain leading to an altered state of consciousness (sub-space)
- Any other rationale
I encouraged participants to respond with one or more numbered options or to provide their own thoughts. The article garnered 102 'loves' and stimulated 224 comments. Among the responses, I recorded 136 relevant replies, revealing that many participants resonated with multiple motivations—leading to a total exceeding 100% for the percentages.
The majority of respondents shared personal anecdotes, and those who answered 'other' provided additional categories of reasons, which I will outline below.
Option 1: Enjoyment of Pain for Its Own Sake
Out of 136 respondents, a significant 101 (74%) affirmed this option. This strong consensus suggests that many masochists genuinely appreciate pain for its intrinsic qualities. However, it's crucial to clarify that not all forms of pain are enjoyable, nor are they pleasurable in every context. Masochists tend to be selective about their experiences, often preferring pain administered in a safe environment by a trusted partner and accompanied by specific rituals. Key preferences include impact pain from activities like spanking and flogging, as well as practices such as shibari, where ropes create tension on the skin.
Moreover, other forms of pain involve clothespins, needles for skin piercing, or hot wax—all generally experienced at moderate levels. Many masochists develop a high tolerance for pain, engaging in practices that might seem torturous to outsiders, but which they find enjoyable.
Some survey participants indicated that their need for pain parallels the intensity of sexual desire, although masochistic experiences are not exclusively sexual.
Option 2: Pain for Humiliation and Ego Reduction
Only 32 of the 136 respondents (24%) identified with this motivation, making it the least chosen option. However, some who selected 'other' expressed a desire for pain to foster feelings of vulnerability and emotional release, which aligns with this concept.
Option 3: Pain as an Expression of Submission
Seventy-six respondents (56%) chose this option, indicating a notable connection between masochism and submission. BDSM encompasses two primary facets: Dominance-Submission (DS), where the submissive surrenders to the dominant, and Sadomasochism (SM), where masochists find pleasure in pain administered by sadists. While many individuals enjoy both elements, some submissives may not derive pleasure from pain but tolerate it to please their dominant partner.
Option 4: Pain Inducing an Altered State of Consciousness
A remarkable 111 respondents (82%) indicated that they seek an altered state of consciousness, commonly referred to as "sub-space," through pain. This state is characterized by a shift in awareness during BDSM interactions, often triggered by the release of adrenaline and noradrenaline, followed by endorphin release that leads to feelings of euphoria.
"My sub-space is a magical place filled with warm beaches and unicorns, where the sun always shines," shared one survey participant, capturing the essence of this sought-after experience.
Option 5: Additional Re