Reassessing Sharia Law: Understanding Female Rationality
Written on
Chapter 1: The Misunderstanding of Female Rationality
Research indicates that maternal genes play a crucial role in governing complex cognitive functions, while paternal genes primarily influence physical attributes like body size.
Growing up, I frequently encountered the notion that "women are more emotional and less rational than men." This statement was often used to justify the disparate treatment I received compared to my brother. He was prioritized for a private education, while my sisters and I were overlooked. As the eldest daughters, we managed family affairs during our father's absence, yet he was treated as the head of the household.
This experience reflects a broader narrative within the Muslim community, particularly among those from Pakistan and India residing in Northern England since the 1960s. Many societies, regardless of their liberal pretensions, often perpetuate these misogynistic views, which align with the prevailing opinions of Islamic scholars and established traditions that deem women as less rational.
The systemic devaluation of women is deeply rooted in these misconceptions. Through media, folklore, and humor, this narrative is reinforced over generations. In Islamic contexts, this gendered perception significantly affects women's roles in families, inheritance rights, and notably, their status as credible witnesses.
Naha Chehade highlights a relevant hadith, stating that women are deemed "deficient in reason" as two women's testimonies are required to equal one man's in court. This principle, derived from Sahih Bukhari, illustrates the underlying biases against women within these religious interpretations.
When I encountered such assertions as a young girl, trying to comprehend why I was labeled "impure" due to menstruation, it became clear to me that these interpretations were simply tools of male control, designed to instill a sense of inferiority and dependence in women.
Section 1.1: The Illogical Basis of Gendered Reasoning
The notion that "two women's testimonies equal one man's" is not merely an abstract legal principle; it reflects a pervasive societal devaluation of women's voices. For instance, if one woman witnesses an event, her testimony alone holds no weight unless corroborated by another woman. In contrast, a single man's account is accepted as valid.
This dynamic extends beyond the courtroom, undermining women's contributions in everyday life. My own experiences echo this reality, as my advice within my family was often disregarded until it became necessary for me to manage the consequences of decisions I had warned against.
For example, I once cautioned my father against involving himself in business dealings with relatives who had previously shown dishonesty. My concerns were ignored, leading to significant familial and financial turmoil.
Section 1.2: The Genetic Insights into Rationality
Recent research is beginning to unravel the complexities of genetic influence on cognitive development. As noted by Annie Foley, studies on gene expression have revealed that certain brain functions are predominantly shaped by maternal genes. Experiments with mouse embryos have shown that the maternal influence correlates with enhanced brain regions responsible for intelligence and complex emotional processing, while paternal genes are linked to larger body sizes and basic instinctual behaviors.
The first video titled "Muslim Feminist Accidentally Discredits Islam (feat. Rationality Rules)" delves into the implications of these discussions, challenging traditional interpretations that reinforce gender biases.
In summary, the maternal impact on cognitive functions is fundamental, contradicting the patriarchal narratives that claim women are inherently less rational. The cultural norms that diminish women's status—such as the expectation for brides to be younger and the legal systems that undermine their authority—highlight the defensive mechanisms men have adopted to maintain control over women.
Chapter 2: Bridging Science and Cultural Norms
The conflict between the truths of nature and patriarchal cultural narratives is evident. Janine LaSalle, a medical microbiologist, emphasizes the significance of maternal influence in areas such as language and social cognition, which are complex and critical for rational thought.
The second video titled "Christopher Hitchens and Tariq Ramadan Debate: Is Islam a Religion of Peace?" engages with these themes, questioning the interpretations of Islamic teachings regarding women's rights.
I urge justice-minded Muslim men to reconsider Sharia law's edicts in light of these scientific revelations. Women, unencumbered by the weight of cultural trauma, possess the rationality and emotional depth that is often overlooked. Societies that promote equality demonstrate that women can excel in various fields, outpacing men in areas like science and academia.