Navigating Our Relationship with Technology: Insights from McLuhan
Written on
Chapter 1: Rethinking Technology
To clarify, this essay does not serve as a moral critique of technology itself. I do not believe that the concept of technology carries an intrinsic moral value. Depending on various circumstances, particular technologies can be deemed beneficial or harmful.
I start with this assertion because critiques of technology often stem from a limited understanding of what it encompasses, which I believe is misguided. If you seek outright condemnation, you won't find much here; I don't align with Luddite perspectives. Conversely, if you anticipate unreserved endorsement, you might be disappointed as well. The discussion surrounding technology is much more nuanced than simply labeling it as good or bad. Reducing it to moral judgments overlooks the substantial dialogues waiting to unfold.
My aim here is to explore how we might better conceptualize technology as an essential element of human life. I question whether we are truly engaging with technology in a meaningful way and whether we grasp its actual implications.
Section 1.1: The Assumptions Surrounding Technology
Our cultural mindset typically embraces an unquestioned acceptance of technology, often fixating on which innovations are superior. This perspective is frequently shaped by marketing strategies and branding that present technology in an alluring manner.
Take the Zoom phenomenon as an example. Our society clung to this platform during a time of crisis, leading to debates about its efficacy and the emergence of “Zoom fatigue.” Some critics labeled Zoom as a societal detriment, while others praised it as a lifeline. Yet, the conversation often stagnated, neglecting the deeper implications of its integration into our lives. Once technologies like Zoom become normalized, they limit our ability to engage in meaningful discussions about their impact.
A common obstacle in our understanding of technology is that we often fail to think critically about it.
Subsection 1.1.1: Questioning Technological Optimism
I must disclose a significant aspect of my viewpoint. I strive to adhere to an ideology known as Agrarianism, primarily articulated by Wendell Berry. This framework challenges the prevailing optimism surrounding technology, which often leads us to believe that continuous advancements will liberate us from our human limitations.
In this mindset, we risk becoming entrapped in a dull present, convinced that the best is yet to come. This belief in technology as a solution to our problems distracts us from deeper conversations about its role in our lives. The relationship we hold with technology resembles a cult-like devotion to the narrative of progress, leaving little room for critical examination. We may question whether a particular technology is beneficial, but we seldom consider the broader implications of our dependence on it.
Chapter 2: Learning from Marshall McLuhan
The first video titled "A different way to think about technology in education: Greg Toppo at TEDxAshburn" offers an insightful examination of how we can approach technology in educational contexts. It challenges conventional views and encourages a more nuanced understanding.
As we transition into a discussion on how to genuinely engage with technology, it is essential to turn our attention to Marshall McLuhan, whose insights remain relevant in our digital era.
The second video titled "Episode 8 - Part 2: WHEN TECHNOLOGY ECHOES YOUR THOUGHTS" delves into the profound effects of technology on our cognition and society, echoing McLuhan’s ideas.
McLuhan, who passed away in 1981, had much to contribute regarding our assumptions about technology and its societal implications. Despite not living in the digital age, he had a remarkable understanding of how technology influences our lives.
Reflecting on my own experiences, I recall the excitement of acquiring my first flip phone at sixteen, only to later feel overshadowed by peers with Blackberries. This illustrates the cyclical nature of technological advancement and our tendency to overlook the sociological dimensions that accompany it.
Section 2.1: Media Ecology and Its Implications
By examining our relationship with technology through McLuhan’s lens, we can better understand the societal norms that shape our perceptions. He emphasized the need to view technology not merely through a moral lens but as a complex force that shapes human interactions and culture.
In a world where technology is constantly evolving, it is crucial to engage in conversations that address the larger context of our dependence on it. McLuhan’s concept of "Media Ecology" provides a framework for understanding how technology reshapes our lives and societies.
Read Part Two:
Media Ecology & How Technology Rewires Us
How to Think About Technology, Part II
[Read the Full Version here: How to Think About Technology]